December 09, 2004
More hermeneutics

Thanks for the nice comments on my last post, and thanks to Mark for pointing out this piece defending a "hermeneutic of trust." The author is responding specifically to feminist deconstructions of the Bible, which he thinks go a little too far:

Sadly, our common history is marked by epidemic violence, including violence against women, children and the powerless. Certainly this violence is to be condemned, and interpreters of the Bible have good grounds for proclaiming such condemnation. The difficulty in which we find ourselves, however, is this: If the Bible itself, the revelatory, identity-defining text of the Christian community, is portrayed as oppressive, on what basis do we know God or relate to God? A corollary question has crucial implications for biblical interpretation: If the Bible is dangerous, on what ground do we stand in conducting a critique of scripture that will render it less harmful?

For Schüssler Fiorenza the answer to the latter question is clear: a feminist critical hermeneutic "does not appeal to the Bible as its primary source but begins with women’s own experience and vision of liberation." Experience (of a certain sort) is treated as unambiguously revelatory, and the Bible is critically scrutinized in its light. Regrettably, many practitioners of the hermeneutics of suspicion, and by no means only feminist interpreters, are remarkably credulous about the claims of experience. As a result, they endlessly critique the biblical texts but rarely get around to hearing scripture’s critique of us or hearing its message of grace.

This seems related, somewhat tangentially, to a post I found via AKMA, on internal vs. external sources of morality. This led to an interesting (but a bit frustrating, for some reason I can't quite name) discussion in the comments about your "Inner Voice" as a source of revelation.

Posted by Camassia at December 09, 2004 12:29 PM | TrackBack

Given your Yoder-blogging, you might be interested in this piece too:

Posted by: Lee on December 9, 2004 01:10 PM

Yeesh! From the look of your Recent Comments listing in the left column, you just got comment-spammed . . . it's ugly!

I went to that post you mentioned on JOHO the Blog, and posted a new comment on it (hasn't appeared yet) about our "two souls" . . .

Posted by: amba on December 12, 2004 11:20 AM
Post a comment
Hi! I'd love to know your thoughts, but please read the rules of commenting:
- You must enter a valid email address
- No sock puppets
- No name-calling or obscene language


Email Address:



Remember info?